IRS & Audits

How Cutler Bay Filers Can Prepare for (and Survive) an IRS Audit

Carlos Rosario 5 min read

Entrance arches of the Internal Revenue Service building in Washington, D.C.
Photo: Carol M. Highsmith / Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The word “audit” makes people picture a stern agent going through every receipt in a windowless room. In reality, most IRS audits are conducted entirely by mail and focus on one or two items. Whether you’ve just received a letter or want to be ready, this guide explains what happens, what to do and how to protect yourself.

  • Most audits are correspondence audits handled by mail; office and field audits are less common.
  • Read the letter carefully, note the response deadline (often 30 days) and never ignore it.
  • Answer only what is asked, with organized copies — never originals.
  • You have rights: representation, appeal and a clear explanation of any change.

How you’ll know it’s a real audit

The IRS starts an audit by mail. It will not open an audit by phone, text or email. Real letters show a notice or letter number (for example Letter 566, CP2000 or Letter 2205), a response deadline and a contact. You can confirm the notice by logging in to your IRS Online Account or by calling the IRS at a number from IRS.gov. If something feels off, read our guide to IRS scams.

The three types of examinations

Type How it works Common topics
Correspondence By mail. You send documents supporting specific items. EITC and dependents, education credits, charitable deductions, Schedule C expenses
Office You (or your representative) meet at an IRS office — South Florida taxpayers are typically assigned to a regional office. Business income and expenses, rental property, larger itemized deductions
Field A revenue agent visits your home or business. Businesses, complex returns, payroll

Not every letter is an audit. A CP2000 is an “underreporter” notice: the IRS’s computers found income reported by a third party (a W-2, 1099 or now a crypto 1099-DA) that isn’t on your return. It proposes changes and gives you 30 days to agree or disagree with documentation. Math-error notices (like CP11 or CP12) correct calculations.

Step-by-step: responding to an audit letter

  1. Don’t panic, don’t ignore. Missing the deadline usually means the IRS assesses the proposed tax and you lose easy appeal options.
  2. Identify exactly what’s being examined. The letter lists the year(s) and items. Focus there.
  3. Pull your return and records for that year: receipts, bank and card statements, invoices, mileage logs, canceled checks, settlement statements.
  4. Get professional help early. With Form 2848 (power of attorney) a qualified representative can speak for you; with Form 8821 we can review your IRS transcripts and correspondence.
  5. Organize a response package: a short cover letter referencing the notice, an index, and clearly labeled copies of documents. Explain anything unusual in plain language.
  6. Send it trackably — certified mail or the IRS Documentation Upload Tool when the letter allows — and keep a full copy.
  7. Need more time? Call or write before the deadline. Reasonable extension requests are commonly granted.

What auditors look for — and what helps

  • Income completeness. Deposits in your bank accounts versus income reported. Keep records of non-taxable deposits (transfers, loans, gifts).
  • Substantiation of expenses. Who, what, when, where and business purpose. For vehicle use, a contemporaneous mileage log; for meals, the business connection.
  • Dependents and credits. School or medical records showing where a child lived; proof of relationship and age.
  • Charitable gifts. Bank records for every gift and written acknowledgments for gifts of $250 or more; appraisals for large non-cash gifts.
Signed contract and fountain pen on a desk
Organized, labeled copies make a correspondence audit faster and less stressful.

Your rights during an audit

The Taxpayer Bill of Rights guarantees, among others, the right to be informed, to quality service, to pay no more than the correct amount of tax, to challenge the IRS’s position and be heard, to appeal in an independent forum, to finality, to privacy, to confidentiality and to retain representation. In practice that means:

  • You can ask why something is being questioned and request a clear explanation of proposed changes.
  • You can have a representative handle the audit; in many cases you don’t need to attend at all.
  • If you disagree with the result, you can request a conference with a manager, go to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals (usually within 30 days of the “30-day letter”), and — after a Notice of Deficiency (the “90-day letter”) — petition the U.S. Tax Court within 90 days without paying first.
  • The Taxpayer Advocate Service can help if you’re facing significant hardship or the IRS isn’t responding.

How far back can the IRS go?

Generally three years from the date you filed (or the due date, if later). It’s six years if you omitted more than 25% of your income, and there is no limit for fraudulent returns or years you didn’t file. That’s why we recommend keeping records for at least seven years — see audit-ready recordkeeping.

After the audit

The outcome is “no change”, an agreed adjustment, or a disagreement you can appeal. If you owe, you can pay in full, set up a payment plan, or request penalty relief where you had reasonable cause. Interest continues until paid, so if you agree with a change, paying sooner saves money. Then fix the cause — better records, better software, or a better preparer — so next year isn’t a repeat.

Frequently asked questions

Does an audit mean the IRS suspects fraud?

No. Most returns are selected because of statistical scoring, mismatches with third-party forms or a specific item such as a credit. Fraud investigations are handled differently.

Should I send everything I have?

No. Send what supports the items under examination. Extra documents can open new questions.

Can I amend my return during an audit?

If you find errors, tell the examiner and provide corrected figures; it’s generally handled within the audit rather than by filing a separate amended return.

Sources

, , ,

Ready for advice you can trust?

Book a free strategy session with our Cutler Bay tax team. We will give you two options for coming in right away.