Every January the ads start: “Maximum refund guaranteed!” “File for $0!” With IRS Direct File discontinued and the 2025 tax law adding new deductions, more Cutler Bay residents are asking whether to do their own taxes or hire a professional. The honest answer: it depends on your return. Here’s how to decide.
- IRS Direct File is gone; free options still exist through IRS Free File partners and volunteer VITA/TCE sites for eligible taxpayers.
- DIY software works well for simple W-2 returns with the standard deduction.
- Self-employment, rental property, crypto, multiple states, IRS letters and the new tips/overtime/senior deductions are where professionals most often find money.
- “Free” software frequently becomes paid once you add schedules — compare the real price.
What happened to IRS Direct File?
Direct File let eligible taxpayers in participating states — Florida included — file simple federal returns directly with the IRS for free in 2024 and 2025. The program was discontinued and was not available for the 2026 filing season. That leaves three main routes for 2027: free options for eligible taxpayers, paid DIY software, or a professional preparer.
Your filing options compared
| Option | Best for | Cost | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| IRS Free File (guided software) | Taxpayers under the annual income limit with straightforward returns | Free if you start from IRS.gov | Starting from a company’s own site may lead to paid upgrades |
| Free File Fillable Forms | Confident filers at any income who know the forms | Free | No guidance or error checking beyond basics |
| VITA / TCE volunteer sites | Low- and moderate-income taxpayers, seniors, people with disabilities, limited-English speakers | Free | Limited scope (no complex businesses or rentals), seasonal hours |
| Commercial DIY software | Simple to moderate returns, comfortable with technology | $0–$200+, plus fees for “live help” | Upsells, add-on fees, you carry the responsibility |
| Professional preparer | Anything beyond simple, or when time and peace of mind matter | Depends on complexity | Choose a preparer who signs the return and has a PTIN |
When DIY software makes sense
- You have W-2 wages, maybe some bank interest, and take the standard deduction.
- No dependents with complicated custody arrangements.
- No self-employment, rental, crypto, stock sales or foreign accounts.
- You didn’t move between states and have no IRS issues.
- You enjoy the process and have time to double-check.
When a professional usually pays for itself
Self-employment and gig work
Rideshare drivers, contractors, real-estate agents and beauty professionals have deductions software can’t see unless you know to look: mileage versus actual vehicle costs, home office, health insurance, retirement plans, the 20% QBI deduction and self-employment tax planning. Mistakes here are among the most common audit triggers.
The new 2025-law deductions
The deductions for qualified tips, overtime premium, seniors and car-loan interest have eligibility rules, phase-outs and documentation requirements. Software asks the questions — but only you can answer them correctly, and many hospitality and healthcare workers don’t know which of their pay qualifies.
Life changes
Marriage, divorce, a new baby, a death in the family, buying or selling a home, an inheritance or a large retirement withdrawal can change filing status, credits and tax brackets in ways that are easy to miss.
Investments and crypto
Basis errors on stocks and crypto can cost thousands. With Form 1099-DA now reporting crypto sales to the IRS, getting it right matters more than ever. See our crypto tax guide.
Anything involving the IRS
Unfiled years, balances due, prior audits or identity theft. Software doesn’t answer IRS letters — we do.

The hidden costs of “free”
Many “free” editions cover only the simplest returns. Add a Schedule C, a 1099-B, a dependent-care credit or a health-savings account and you may be prompted to upgrade, then offered “audit defense”, “refund transfer” and “live help” add-ons. Before you start, compare the final price — including the cost of your own time — with a professional quote.
How to choose a professional
- Check the PTIN. Every paid preparer must have one and sign your return. Verify credentials in the IRS Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers.
- Avoid fees based on refund size or anyone who wants your refund deposited in their account.
- Ask about year-round availability. Who answers if the IRS writes in August?
- Expect questions. A good preparer interviews you; a bad one just types in forms.
- Review before you sign, and get a copy of everything filed.
The middle path: DIY with a professional review
Some clients prepare their own return and book a review session before filing. We check for missed deductions, filing-status choices and errors that trigger notices. If we find nothing, you file with confidence; if we find something, it often pays for the session.
Frequently asked questions
Is software less accurate than a person?
Software does the math correctly. Errors come from inputs — wrong filing status, missed income, deductions you didn’t know to claim. A professional’s value is asking the right questions.
Can I switch from software to a professional mid-way?
Yes. Bring a PDF of your draft return and documents; we’ll review and finish it.
Do I need a state return in Florida?
No personal state income tax return is required for Florida residents. Be careful with software that charges for a “state return” you don’t need.